-
When to Use This Checklist
-
Step 1: Verify Regulatory Standing Before You Discuss Price
-
Step 2: Demand a Total Cost of Ownership Breakdown
-
Step 3: Ask What They're Not Good At
-
Step 4: Audit the Clinical Support Structure
-
Step 5: Verify Consumable Supply Continuity
-
Step 6: Test Response Time With a Live Question
-
Step 7: Lock In a Measurable Trial Period
-
What to Watch Out For
When to Use This Checklist
If you're sourcing anything from infusion pumps to ultrasound machines to incontinence products, and you're about to sign a contract above, say, $10,000—this is for you. I've been managing our device procurement budget for six years now. We're a 400-person health system, and I've negotiated with somewhere around 45 suppliers over that stretch. Some good. Some not.
Here's the thing: most procurement guides tell you to "do your due diligence." That's not actionable. What follows is the actual seven-step checklist I run before any significant device purchase. No fluff. Just what I do, in order.
Step 1: Verify Regulatory Standing Before You Discuss Price
I know it's tempting to start with the quote. Don't. Before I take a meeting with a sales rep, I pull the manufacturer's FDA registration and check for 510(k) clearance on the specific device class. The FDA's public database makes this straightforward—search the establishment name, confirm the registration is active, and cross-reference the product code.
What I'm looking for: an active registration, no warning letters in the past 24 months, and a clearance number that matches the actual product being pitched. I've caught two suppliers over the years who were selling a cleared device but quoting a modified version that hadn't gone through the process. Not ideal.
Checkpoint: You should be able to answer "yes" to all three—registration active, no open FDA enforcement actions, product matches clearance.
Step 2: Demand a Total Cost of Ownership Breakdown
The sticker price is the least useful number in the conversation. What I ask for is a line-item TCO sheet covering: device cost, installation and setup, clinical training hours, consumables for year one, extended warranty, and expected service intervals.
Example from last year: we were comparing two ultrasound machine proposals. Vendor A quoted $42,000. Vendor B quoted $38,500. Sounds like an easy call, right? Then I got the TCO sheets. Vendor B charged $1,800 for installation, $2,200 annual for a service contract that Vendor A included, and their probe warranty was 12 months versus 36. Over four years, Vendor B was actually about $6,000 more expensive. That's a 15% swing hidden in the fine print.
I still kick myself for not demanding TCO sheets on an earlier incontinence product order. We went with the lower quote and ended up paying nearly double per-unit on replacement pads because we hadn't checked the consumable pricing structure. A lesson learned the hard way.
Checkpoint: You have a written TCO comparison covering at least a 3-year horizon, with all recurring costs itemized.
Step 3: Ask What They're Not Good At
This is the step most buyers skip. I ask every supplier, directly: "What part of your portfolio is weaker than your competitors'? Where would you tell me to look elsewhere?"
The responses are revealing. Some reps get visibly uncomfortable. Others launch into a rehearsed "we're strong across the board" speech. But the good ones—and this has happened maybe five times in six years—will actually say something like, "Our syringe pump line is our core strength, but if you need a specialty pump for high-viscosity fluids, we're not the best fit and I'd rather you know that."
That kind of honesty earns my trust for everything else. A specialist who knows their limits is more reliable than a generalist who overpromises. I'd rather work with a supplier who tells me where the boundary is than one who claims to do everything.
Checkpoint: The rep gave you at least one specific area where they're not the strongest option. If they couldn't name one, that's a data point too.
Step 4: Audit the Clinical Support Structure
Training and clinical support aren't nice-to-haves for medical devices—they're part of the product. What I check: How many field clinical specialists cover our region? What's the average response time for on-site support? Do they have a documented escalation path, or does everything route through a general customer service line?
For infection control-related equipment, I also ask for their cleaning validation documentation and whether they offer ongoing education on proper reprocessing. If a supplier can't produce that, it tells me they haven't invested in the clinical side of their business.
I don't have hard data on industry-wide support response benchmarks, but based on our internal ticket tracking, the difference between a well-staffed support network and a thin one is roughly a 3x gap in resolution time. That translates directly into staff downtime during implementation.
Checkpoint: You know the name and contact info of your assigned clinical specialist, and you've confirmed their coverage territory includes your facility.
Step 5: Verify Consumable Supply Continuity
This is the one that bites people two years post-purchase. For any device with proprietary consumables—infusion sets, syringes, incontinence pads, sensor arrays—I ask for their fill-rate history over the past 12 months and their contingency plan for supply disruptions.
I want to see: a stated fill rate above 95%, a secondary manufacturing or distribution site, and a documented allocation policy for backorder situations. We once had a vendor whose single production facility had a three-week shutdown. Nobody told us until we were down to our last two cases of consumables. That's a supply chain risk I now screen for upfront.
Checkpoint: You have a written fill-rate commitment and a named backup distribution point.
Step 6: Test Response Time With a Live Question
Before I sign anything, I send a real technical question to their support or sales engineering team. Something specific enough that it requires actual knowledge—not a canned response. Then I time the reply.
I'm not looking for instant. I'm looking for whether they engage substantively within, say, two business days. If they can't answer a pre-sale technical question promptly, the post-sale experience rarely improves. I've never fully understood why some vendors drop off after the contract is signed—my best guess is that it comes down to how they allocate account management resources—but the pre-sale response time is a decent proxy.
Checkpoint: You received a substantive reply (not a "let me check and get back to you" placeholder) within two business days.
Step 7: Lock In a Measurable Trial Period
"Satisfaction guaranteed" means nothing. What I negotiate instead is a defined trial period with specific, measurable criteria for success. For an infusion pump rollout, that might be: 30 days of clinical use, no more than two device-related workflow interruptions, and a documented staff satisfaction score above 80%.
If those metrics aren't met, we have a defined path to return or replace—in writing, before the order is placed. This isn't about being adversarial. It's about making sure both sides agree on what "working well" actually means.
Checkpoint: The trial criteria, duration, and remedy are spelled out in the contract, not just in an email.
What to Watch Out For
The "one-stop shop" pitch. Be cautious when a supplier claims to cover all your device categories equally well. In my experience, breadth usually means average depth. A company that's genuinely strong in, say, infusion systems and airway management is telling you something—they've chosen to be excellent at those things rather than adequate at everything.
Geographic distance matters less than you think—but not zero. A supplier with a distribution center in Minnesota can often beat a local vendor on response time if their logistics are better organized. Don't assume local automatically means faster. Check the actual support infrastructure.
Infection control claims need documentation. "Easy to clean" is a marketing phrase. "Validated cleaning protocol with published efficacy data" is what you need for your accreditation file. Ask for the latter.
Don't skip the reference calls. I know this sounds obvious, but I've seen procurement teams skip references because "the demo went well." Ask three current customers—not the ones the vendor picked, if you can find them independently—what surprised them after the purchase. The surprises are where the real information lives.